Section ACW: Descendants of Elisha Mitchell

David Thaler
18043 NE 132nd St, Redmond WA 98052
Send questions and corrections to: dthaler@microsoft.com

Report generated by MagiCensus Deluxe v5.1.0 on 29 June 2017
http://www.themagikey.com/
From Thaler_export.ged


Generation One

1. ELISHA1 MITCHELL was born in 1770[128] in New York, United States[128], died between 20 Aug. 1830 and 31 Dec. 1830[128] in Keswick, York Co., Ontario, Canada[157] and was buried in 1830[130] in Keswick[130]. He married before 1797[129], SARAH SMITH, who was born in 1773[129] in New York[74, 110, 104], and died in 1875[129] in Rock Co., Minnesota, United States[129]. [128, 130, 157, 156, 139]
Elaine Pavone's database online claims that Zebediah4 (Experience3, John2, Experience1) Mitchell (b. 1734) and Anne Bartlett married in 1754 and had children Darius, Anna, Elisha, and Avis. The present Elisha had children, among others, named Darius, Elisha, and Avis. The confluence of names seems too close to be a mere coincidence. Further research is needed on this line.[160]
In "Rhode Island in the Colonial Wars", an Elisha Mitchell of Rhode Island is listed as having served in Capt. Jenckes' Co. in 1757, in Capt. Rose's Co. in 1758, in campaign of 1759, in Col Harris' Regt. in 1760, and in Capt. Hawkins' Co. in 1762. http://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Mitchell-8203 also notes "Based in Fort Orange near Albany NY", apparently from "List of Rhode Island Solders & Sailors in the Old French and Indian War 1755-1762", p.191.[158]
An Elisha Mitchell appears in the 1790 census in Easton, Albany Co., NY:
2 males 16+
1 male 0-16
4 females

No Elisha Mitchell appears in New York in the 1800 census.[43]
Elisha has a land petition in Gwillimbury, Ontario in 1801. An online source has this elaboration: Ontario Archive "Petition of Elisha Mitchell late of the State of New York, but now of the Township of Gwillimbury" Land petition York 19th May 1801, citing "Land petition in Ontario archive Reel C 2194 (1-187) Upper Canada Land Petitions 1800-1801. M Bundle 5 No.127",[156]
From the 7 Aug. 1820 census, in Freeport, Ontario, New York:
Elisha Mitchell
1 Free White male 0-10
1 Free White male 45+
2 Free White females 0-10
1 Free White female 16-26
2 Free White females 45+

From the 1 June 1840 census, in Lima, Livingston Co., New York:
Elisha Mitchell
1 Free White male 70-80
1 Free White female 70-80

However, these appear to be a different Elisha Mitchell, since children Avis and Nelson both married in North Gwillimbury in the 1830s. Also the obituary of probable daughter Dorcas Willoughby says "Dorcas Mitchell was born near Toronto, Canada, Oct. 4, 1804. When she was two years old her parents moved to Lake Simcoe, Davidtown, Canada. Here she spent her girlhood and grew up among her nine brothers and sisters."

Elisha is listed on a number of other sites as the supposed father, but no sources are cited.[133]
In 1801, Elisha signed a land petition stating
"To his Excellency Peter Hunter Esquire Lieutenant Governor of Upper Canada
In Council
The Petition of Elisha Mitchell late of the State of New York, but now of the Township of Gwillimbury in this province.
19th May 1801 signed Elisha Mitchell"[159]
Children:
+2i.DARIUS2 MITCHELL, b. in 1797[129] in Ontario[89]; m. MARY LOUISE WILLOUGHBY, b. in Ontario[112], d. before 1881[90].
+3ii.DORCAS MITCHELL, b. in 1804[141] in New York[95]; d. on 27 Dec. 1906[133] in Holt, Ingham Co., Michigan, United States[133]; m. in 1821[133] (ATH-2) JOHN WILLOUGHBY, b. in New York[93] on 22 June 1787[134], d. in Aurelius, Ingham Co.[134] on 22 March 1871[134], son of (ATH-1) _____ WILLOUGHBY.
+4iii.ELISHA MITCHELL, b. about 1810 in Vermont, United States[73]; d. before 1851[137]; m. (WA-60) ALTHEA HUNTLEY, b. in Vermont[107], daughter of (WA-55) Bethuel and (KL-2) Eunice (CHURCH) HUNTLEY.
+5iv.DIADEMA MITCHELL, b. in 1809[141] in Canada West, Canada[61]; d. in 1886[141]; m. in 1833[141] (ATH-3) BENJAMIN WILLOUGHBY, b. in Canada West[61], son of (ATH-1) _____ WILLOUGHBY.
+6v.AVIS MITCHELL, b. about 1813[136] in Canada[109]; m. on 8 Sept. 1835[136] in North Gwillimbury, York Co.[136] (EQ-1) AQUILLA BENNETT JR., b. in York Co.[136].
+7vi.NELSON MITCHELL, b. about 2 May 1814 in Ontario[34, 58]; m. on 8 April 1839[140, 122] in North Gwillimbury[140, 122] ELIZABETH OGLEBY, b. in Ontario[58].
+8vii.NOAH MITCHELL, b. about 1821 in Ontario[57]; d. in Oct. 1895[125] in Texas, United States[125]; m. about 1844[125] (TU-2) ELIZABETH HAINES, b. in Ontario[57], d. in Texas[125] in Oct. 1895[125], daughter of (TU-1) George and Diana (_____) HAINES.
9viii.NATHANIEL MITCHELL, b. about 1810.
10ix.CANDACE MITCHELL, b. about 1810.


Generation Two

2. DARIUS2 MITCHELL (Elisha1), son of (1) Elisha1 and Sarah (SMITH) MITCHELL, was born in 1797[129] in Ontario[89], and died between 4 April 1881 and 1902. He married MARY LOUISE WILLOUGHBY, who was born in Ontario[112], and died before 1881[90].

From the 12 Jan. 1852 census, in North Gwillimbury[113]:

NameOccupationBirthplaceAge at Next BirthdayGenderMarital Status
Darius MitchellyeomanCanada55M
Louisa MitchellCanada45FM
Alexander MitchellCanada18M
Laurilla MitchellCanada17F
Sarah MitchellCanada15F
Josiah MitchellCanada12MS
Philana MitchellCanada10FS
Nelson MitchellCanada3MS

From the 2 April 1871 census, in Georgina, York North, Ontario[112]:

Dwelling #Family #NameGenderAge at Next BirthdayBirthplaceReligionOriginOccupationMarital Status
140141Mitchell, DariusM80United StatesB. ChristianEnglishLabourerM
Mitchell, MaryF73OntarioB. ChristianEnglishM
Mitchell, NelsonM21OntarioB. ChristianEnglishLabourer
Anderson, WilliamM43OntarioB. ChristianScotchLabourerM
Anderson, SarahF38OntarioB. Christiannot knownM
Anderson, MatildaF7OntarioB. ChristianScotch

From the 4 April 1881 census, in North Gwillimbury[89]:

Dwelling #Family #NameGenderAgeBirthplaceReligionOriginOccupationMarital Status
184188Mitchell, NelsonM25OntarioMethodistEnglishLabourerM
Mitchell, ElizaF27OntarioMethodistEnglishM
Mitchell, EdwardM13OntarioMethodistEnglish
Mitchell, JamesM11OntarioMethodistEnglish
Mitchell, JohnM9OntarioMethodistEnglish
Mitchell, MaggieM6OntarioMethodistEnglish
Mitchell, CharlesM2OntarioMethodistEnglishFarm laborerS
Mitchell, DariusM65OntarioMethodistEnglishyeomanW

[129, 100, 105, 36, 4, 76, 89, 112, 113]
From Canadian Immigrant Records:
Name: Darius Mitchell
Year of Record: 1875
Source/Event: Statement showing Militiamen of 1812-1815 who have applied to participate in the gratuity voted by Parliament in 1875.
Comments: Militiaman (1812-1815)
Age: 79
Reference: National Library of Canada: Parliamentary Sessional Papers, 1876, No. 7 page 61[152]
Since evidence indicates that the first Darius (b. 1797) did not die young, information that there was a second Darius appears dubious.[129]
Children:
+11i.CHARLES W.3 MITCHELL, b. about 1832[44] in Ontario[57]; d. between 1870 and 1877; m. (ANQ-2) SARA ANN SWEET, b. in Ontario[57] about 1842[44, 47], d. in Ravenna, Muskegon Co., Michigan[114] in 1894[114], daughter of (ANQ-1) _____ and Elenor (_____) SWEET.
12ii.ALEXANDER MITCHELL, b. in 1835[120] in Canada[113]; m. on 12 Oct. 1892[120] in Port Huron, St. Clair, Michigan[120] ELIZA JANE GRIFFIN, b. in Canada[120] in 1837[120].
13iii.LAURILLA MITCHELL, b. about 1835 in Canada[113].
14iv.SARAH MITCHELL, b. on 28 Jan. 1838[4] in Canada[4]; d. on 9 May 1914[4, 127] in Sullivan Twp., Muskegon Co.[4, 127]; m. WILLIAM ANDERSON, b. in Ontario[112].
+15v.JOSIAH MITCHELL, b. about March 1840 in Canada[113, 17, 105, 105]; m. ARVILLA _____, b. in Ohio, United States[17].
16vi.PHILANA MITCHELL, b. about 1842 in Canada[113].
+17vii.NELSON MITCHELL, b. in 1850[123] in North Gwillimbury[123]; m. (1) on 13 Dec. 1872[123] in Orillia, Simcoe Co., Ontario[123] AGNES WELWOOD, b. in Nasagarwga, Ontario[123] in 1853[123]; m. (2) on 17 Sept. 1878[124] in Georgina, York, Ontario[124] ELIZA SHUTTLEWORTH, b. in Ontario[89] in Aug. 1846[111].
18viii.SUSANNA ROSE MITCHELL, b. about 1826[144].
+19ix.SOPHIA MITCHELL, b. on 27 Aug. 1826[142, 155] in Canada West[59]; d. on 6 Nov. 1910[118] in North Gwillimbury[118]; m. (AHV-1) GEORGE PRINGLE, b. in Canada West[59] in 1830[154], d. in Georgina, York[154] in 1894[154].
+20x.NATHAN MITCHELL, b. on 30 June 1829[149] in Ontario[37, 79, 60]; d. on 30 Oct. 1900[149, 115] in Scott, Ontario[149, 115]; m. SARAH ANN TOMLINSON, b. in Ontario[37, 79, 60] on 4 Oct. 1837[150], d. in Georgina, York[117] on 19 Feb. 1884[117].
3. DORCAS2 MITCHELL (Elisha1), daughter of (1) Elisha1 and Sarah (SMITH) MITCHELL, was born in 1804[141] in New York[95], and died on 27 Dec. 1906[133] in Holt[133]. She married in 1821[133], (ATH-2) JOHN WILLOUGHBY, son of (ATH-1) _____ WILLOUGHBY, who was born on 22 June 1787[134] in New York[93], and died on 22 March 1871[134] in Aurelius[134].

From the 1 June 1840 census, in Putnam, Livingston Co., Michigan[96]:

Name: John Willoughby
1 Free White male 0-5 (Elisha 2)
1 Free White male 10-15 (Samuel 9)
1 Free White male 40-50 (John 52)
2 Free White females 0-5 (Esther 5, Chloe Ann 3)
1 Free White female 5-10 (Candace 8)
1 Free White female 10-15 (Margaret 12)
1 Free White female 30-40 (Dorcas 35-37)

From the 1 June 1850 census, in Aurelius[93]:

Dwelling #Family #NameAgeGenderOccupationBirthplaceAttended School Within the YearCannot Read and Write
866870John Willoughby55MFarmerNew YorkY
Dorcas Willoughby44FCanadaY
Samuel Willoughby21MCanada
Candace Willoughby18FCanadaY
Esther Willoughby15FCanada
Chole Willoughby13FCanadaY
Elisha Willoughby12MOhio
William Willoughby7MMichiganY
Mary L. Willoughby5FMichiganY
Nelson Willoughby4MMichigan

From the 1 June 1870 census, in Aurelius[94]:

Dwelling #Family #NameAgeGenderColorOccupationReal Estate ValuePersonal Estate ValueBirthplaceFather Foreign BornMother Foreign BornAttended School Within the YearCannot ReadCannot WriteMale Citizen Over 21
2526Willoughby, John83MWRetired FarmerCanadaYYY
Willoughby, Dorcas72FWKeeping houseCANYY
Willoughby, William26MWFarmer3600800MIYYYYY
Willoughby, Susan25FWKeeping houseNew York
Willoughby, Eugene1MWMichigan
Herrick, John12MWAt homeMichiganY

From the 1 June 1880 census, in Aurelius[95]:

Dwelling #Family #NameColorGenderAgeRelationshipMarital StatusOccupationBirthplaceFather's BirthplaceMother's Birthplace
3132Herrick, JohnWhiteM22HeadSFarmerMichiganNew YorkCanada
Willoughby, DorcasWhiteF68GrandmotherWdHouse KeeperNew YorkCanadaCanada
Willoughby, EugeneWhiteM13CousinSMichiganCanadaMichigan

From the 1 June 1884 census, in Aurelius[153]:

Dwelling #Family #NameAgeGenderRelationshipMarital StatusBirthplaceFather's BirthplaceMother's BirthplaceProfessionYears in State
4244Herrick, John A.26MHeadMMichiganMichiganMichiganFarmer
Herrick, Rosa19FwifeMOhioPennsylvaniaPennsylvania18
4345Herrick, James R.24MbrotherMMichiganMichiganMichiganFarmer
Herrick, Libby17FwifeMMichiganMichiganMichigan
Willoughby, Dorcas78FgrandmotherWCanadaNYNYKeeping house45

From the 1 June 1894 census, in Aurelius[98]:

NameAgeGenderRelationshipMarital StatusBirthplaceFather's BirthplaceMother's BirthplaceProfession
Charles Hall26M
Dorcas Willaby89FGrandmotherWCANNYNYKeeping house
Adelia Willaby20FWife

[129, 141, 133, 49, 45, 94, 95, 41, 93, 96, 97, 98, 153]
Children: See (ATH-2) John WILLOUGHBY
4. ELISHA2 MITCHELL (Elisha1), son of (1) Elisha1 and Sarah (SMITH) MITCHELL, was born in Vermont[73], and died between 1836 and 1851[137]. He married (WA-60) ALTHEA HUNTLEY, daughter of (WA-55) Bethuel and (KL-2) Eunice (CHURCH) HUNTLEY, who was born in Vermont[107]. [137, 138, 129]
Child:
+21i.SYLVANUS3 MITCHELL, b. in June 1828[73] in Canada West[71, 70]; m. ANNA _____, b. in New York[73] in July 1835[73].
5. DIADEMA2 MITCHELL (Elisha1), daughter of (1) Elisha1 and Sarah (SMITH) MITCHELL, was born in 1809[141] in Canada West[61], and died in 1886[141]. She married in 1833[141], (ATH-3) BENJAMIN WILLOUGHBY, son of (ATH-1) _____ WILLOUGHBY, who was born in Canada West[61].

From the 12 Jan. 1852 census, in North Gwillimbury[108]:

NameOccupationBirthplaceAge at Next BirthdayGenderMarital StatusBorn During 1851Houses|KindHouses|Stories
Benjamin WilloughbyLabourerCanada45MMLog1
Diana WilloughbyCanada46FM
Ezuba WilloughbyCanada18FS
Larne WilloughbyCanada16FS
Hannah WilloughbyCanada14FS
George WilloughbyCanada13MS
Mary WilloughbyCanada10FS
John HulstockLaborerEngland25MM
Rosa HulstockCanada20FM
Maria HulstockCanada2FS
Ellice HulstockCanada1MSY

From the 14 Jan. 1861 census, in North Gwillimbury[61]:

NameOccupationBirthplaceReligionAge at Next BirthdayGenderMarital StatusCannot Read and Write
Benjamin WilloubyLabourerCanada West53MMY
Diademia WilloubyCanada West52FMY
Zuby WilloubyCanada West27FSY
Mary WilloubyCanada West19FS
Maria WillougbyCanada West11FS
William WilloubyCanada West9MS
Loris PearsonCanada West25FMY
Hester PearsonCanada West6FS
William PearsonCanada West2MS
Sarah WilloubyCanada WestMethodist3FS

From the 2 April 1871 census, in North Gwillimbury[64]:

Dwelling #Family #NameGenderAge at Next BirthdayBirthplaceReligionOriginOccupationMarital StatusAttending SchoolCannot ReadCannot Write
5252Willoughby, BenjaminM57OntarioMethodistScotchFarmerMYY
Willoughby, DiademaF63OntarioMethodistMY
Willoughby, AlfredM17OntarioMethodistScotchY
Willoughby, SarahF12OntarioMethodistScotchY

From the 4 April 1881 census, in North Gwillimbury[92]:

Dwelling #Family #NameGenderAgeBirthplaceReligionOriginOccupationMarital Status
210214Willoughby, BenjaminM72ONMethodistEnglishLabourerM
Willoughby, DiademiaF72ONMethodistEnglishM

[129, 141, 102, 108, 78, 35, 64, 92, 92, 31, 61]
Children: See (ATH-3) Benjamin WILLOUGHBY
6. AVIS2 MITCHELL (Elisha1), daughter of (1) Elisha1 and Sarah (SMITH) MITCHELL, was born about 1813[136] in Canada[109], and died between 12 Jan. 1852 and 1925. She married in North Gwillimbury[136], on 8 Sept. 1835[136], (EQ-1) AQUILLA BENNETT JR., who was born in York Co.[136].

From the 12 Jan. 1852 census, in North Gwillimbury[109]:

NameOccupationBirthplaceAge at Next BirthdayGenderMarital StatusFamily MemberAbsent
Abram TunkyBlacksmithCanada53MM
Hannah TunkyEngland29FM
Elijah TunkyCanada17MSY
James TunkyCanada10MS
Sarah TunkyCanada8DS
Matilda TunkyCanada6DS
Emma A. TunkyCanada4DS
Avis BennettCanada38FMN
Altha BennettCanada3FSN
Infant BennettCanada1FSN

[129, 136, 103, 109]
Children: See (EQ-1) Aquilla BENNETT Jr.
7. NELSON2 MITCHELL (Elisha1), son of (1) Elisha1 and Sarah (SMITH) MITCHELL, was born in Ontario[34, 58], and died between May 1875 and 1924. He married in North Gwillimbury[140, 122], on 8 April 1839[140, 122], ELIZABETH OGLEBY, who was born in Ontario[58].

From the 12 Jan. 1852 census, in North Gwillimbury[110]:

NameOccupationBirthplaceReligionAge at Next BirthdayGenderMarital StatusFamily MemberAttending SchoolHouses|KindHouses|Stories
Nelson MitchellyeomanCanadaUnitarian Christian Church38MMFrame2
Elizabeth MitchellCanadaUnitarian Christian Church26FM
Bartlett MitchellCanadaUnitarian Christian Church12MSY
Clarissa MitchellCanadaUnitarian Christian Church8FSY
Salla MitchellCanadaUnitarian Christian Church6FSY
Seth MitchellCanadaUnitarian Christian Church4MSY
Emily MitchellCanadaUnitarian Christian Church2FS
Sarah MitchellNew YorkUnitarian Christian Church78FW
Nathaniel MitchellLabourerCanadaChristian23MSN
Cloe MitchellCanada40FMN
Mary MitchellCanada2FSN

From the 14 Jan. 1861 census, in North Gwillimbury[58]:

NameOccupationBirthplaceReligionAge at Next BirthdayGenderMarital StatusAttending School Within the Year
Nelson MitchellyeomanOntarioChristian48MM
Elizabeth MitchellOntarioChristian38FM
Ezra Bartlett MitchellOntarioChristian21MS
Claracy MitchellOntarioChristian17FSY
Sarah MitchellOntarioChristian15FSY
Seth MitchellOntarioChristian13MSY
Nelson MitchellOntarioChristian9MSY
Elisha MitchellOntarioChristian8MSY
Frances MitchellOntarioChristian5MS
Hugh MitchellOntarioChristian3MS
Sarah MitchellUnited StatesChristian85FS

From the 2 April 1871 census, in Canada[34]:

Dwelling #Family #NameGenderAge at Next BirthdayBirthplaceReligionOriginOccupationMarital Status
4848Mitchell, NelsonM57ONChristianScotchFarmerW
Mitchell, SarahF97United StatesChristianEnglishW
Mitchell, SethM25ONChristianScotchFarmer
Mitchell, NelsonM18ONChristianScotchFarmer
Mitchell, ElishaM16ONChristianScotchFarmer
Mitchell, FrancisM14ONChristianScotch
Mitchell, HughM12ONChristianScotchS
Mitchell, VeronaF10OntarioChristianScotchS
Mitchell, LenoraF6OntarioChristianScotchS

From the 1 May 1875 census, in Minnesota[74]:

Family #NameAgeGenderColorBirthplaceFather's BirthplaceMother's BirthplaceCondition
20Nelson Mitchell60MWCanadaCanadaCanada
Seth Mitchell25MWCanadaCanadaCanada
Nelson Mitchell23MWCanadaCanadaCanada
Elisha Mitchell20MWCanadaCanadaCanada
Frances Mitchell19MWCanadaCanadaCanada
Hugh Mitchell17MWCanadaCanadaCanada
Verrona Mitchell13FWCanadaCanadaCanada
Lunnari Mitchell11FWCanadaCanadaCanada
Sarah Mitchell102FWNew YorkCanadaCanadaOldest person in the county

[129, 32, 33, 34, 74, 104, 110, 58]
Children:
+22i.EZRA BARTLETT3 MITCHELL, b. about Feb. 1841 in Ontario[67, 58]; m. SUSAN _____, b. in Ireland[67].
23ii.CLARISSA MITCHELL, b. about 1844 in Ontario[58].
24iii.SALLA MITCHELL, b. about 1846 in Ontario[58].
25iv.SETH MITCHELL, b. about 1848 in Ontario[34, 58].
26v.EMILY MITCHELL, b. about 1850 in Canada[110].
27vi.NELSON MITCHELL, b. about 1852 in Ontario[34, 58].
28vii.ELISHA MITCHELL, b. about 1854 in Ontario[34, 58].
29viii.FRANCES MITCHELL, b. about 1856 in Ontario[34, 58].
30ix.HUGH MITCHELL, b. about 1858 in Ontario[34, 58].
31x.VERONA MITCHELL, b. about 1861 in Ontario[34].
32xi.LENORA MITCHELL, b. about 1864 in Ontario[34].
8. NOAH2 MITCHELL (Elisha1), son of (1) Elisha1 and Sarah (SMITH) MITCHELL, was born in Ontario[57], and died in Oct. 1895[125] in Texas[125]. He married about 1844[125], (TU-2) ELIZABETH HAINES, daughter of (TU-1) George and Diana (_____) HAINES, who was born in Ontario[57], and died in Oct. 1895[125] in Texas[125].

From the 1 June 1850 census, in Ellington, Brown Co., Wisconsin, United States[68]:

Dwelling #Family #NameAgeGenderOccupationReal Estate ValueBirthplace
117117Noah Mitchell33MFarmer300Canada
Elizabeth Mitchell22FKeeps HouseCanada
Elisha Benett10MCanada
David Perl32MCarpenterConnecticut
Marshall Mitchell2MFarmerCanada

From the 14 Jan. 1861 census, in North Gwillimbury[57]:

NameOccupationBirthplaceReligionAge at Next BirthdayGenderMarital Status
Charles MitchelLabourerON20MM
Sally A. MitchelKeeping houseONno denomination19FM
Nancy PringleON16FS
Noah MitchelLabourerON45MM
Betsey MitchelON30FM
Mary MitchelUSA5F

From the 1 June 1870 census, in Ravenna, Muskegon, Michigan[17]:

Dwelling #Family #NameAgeGenderColorOccupationReal Estate ValuePersonal Estate ValueBirthplaceFather Foreign BornMother Foreign BornCannot ReadCannot Write
194183Mitchell Noah55MWFarmer4002550CanadaYYYY
Mitchell Betsey42FWKeeps HouseCanadaYYYY
Mitchell Mary14FWCanadaYYYY
Mitchell David G.H.1MWMichiganYY
195184Mitchell, Josiah30MWLabourCanadaYY
Mitchell, Arvilla26FWKeeps HouseOhio
Mitchell, James2MWMichiganY

From the 1 June 1880 census, in Kauffman Co., Texas[23]:

NameGenderAgeRelationshipMarital StatusOccupationBirthplaceFather's BirthplaceMother's Birthplace
Mitchell NoahM58HeadMFarmingCANNYVT
Mitchell ElizabethF51wifeMKeeping houseCANNYCAN
Mitchell DavidM11sonSFarm laborerMICANCAN

[114, 125, 23, 10, 99, 56, 68, 15, 16, 17, 15, 57]
http://docs.google.com/Doc?id=ddzw62ms_26hsvptvcp
Parents of Noah seem probable, based on:
1) In the 1850 census, Noah has, living with him, Elisha Bennett age 10, born in Canada.
2) In April 1851, Noah and Sylvanus are both in the same location (Ellington, Wisconsin), with no other Mitchell families.
3) In the 1851 census, Althea Mitchel age 53 is found in North Gwillimbury Ontario, where Noah is later found in 1861. Althea is reportedly living with Avis (Mitchell) Bennett, probably her daughter, and widow of Aquilla Bennett Jr.
4) On January 24, 1863, in North Gwillimbury Twp., Elisha Bennett son of Aquilla and Avis (Mitchell) Bennett married Philinda Mitchell.
5) In the 1870 census, Sylvanus has, living with him, Althea Mitchel age 69, born in "Canada E(nglish)".
6) In the 1880 census, Elisha Bennett age "36" born in Canada is found with wife Philinda age 30, born in Canada, in Ravenna, Muskegon Co., Michigan where Noah Mitchell was found in the 1870 census.
Children:
33i.PHEBE ANN3 MITCHELL, b. in June 1845[62] in Ontario[65, 63, 60]; d. in 1923[125] in Oregon, United States[125]; m. in 1864[125] THOMAS T. MILLS, b. in Roxburgh, Scotland, United Kingdom in Jan. 1838[62], d. in Oregon[125] in 1926[125].
+34ii.MARSHALL MITCHELL, b. about 1849 in Ontario[60]; d. between 14 Jan. 1861 and 1959; m. (ANQ-2) SARA ANN SWEET, b. in Ontario[57] about 1842[44, 47], d. in Ravenna, Muskegon Co.[114] in 1894[114], daughter of (ANQ-1) _____ and Elenor (_____) SWEET.
35iii.MARY E. MITCHEL, b. about 15 Jan. 1856 in United States[57]; d. between June 1870 and 1966; m. in 1876[125] JOHN P. EASTERLY.
36iv.DAVID GEORGE H. MITCHELL, b. about 1869 in Michigan[23, 17, 15, 15, 15, 15, 15, 15, 16]; d. in 1948 in Carter Co., Oklahoma, United States; m. in 1893 ODELLIA MURPHY.
http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.ancestry.com/~mitchell001/noah_mitchell.html

Generation Three

11. CHARLES W.3 MITCHELL (Darius2, Elisha1), son of (2) Darius2 and Mary Louise (WILLOUGHBY) MITCHELL, was born about 1832[44] in Ontario[57], and died between June 1870 and Dec. 1877. He married in York Co.[114], (ANQ-2) SARA ANN SWEET, daughter of (ANQ-1) _____ and Elenor (_____) SWEET, who was born about 1842[44, 47] in Ontario[57], and died in 1894[114] in Ravenna, Muskegon Co.[114].

From the 14 Jan. 1861 census, in North Gwillimbury[57]:

NameOccupationBirthplaceReligionAge at Next BirthdayGenderMarital Status
Charles MitchelLabourerON20MM
Sally A. MitchelKeeping houseONno denomination19FM
Nancy PringleON16FS
Noah MitchelLabourerON45MM
Betsey MitchelON30FM
Mary MitchelUSA5F

From the 1 June 1870 census, in Ada, Kent Co., Michigan[14]:

Dwelling #Family #NameAgeGenderColorOccupationPersonal Estate ValueBirthplaceFather Foreign BornMother Foreign BornRight to Vote Denied
4647Mitchell Charles37MWFarmer600CANYYY
Mitchell Sarah27FWKeeping houseCANY
Mitchell Nathan9MWCANYY
Mitchell Matilda1FWMIYY

[114, 44, 11, 57, 14, 11, 12, 13]
Charles and Sarah came to Ravenna, Michigan, in 1868 with Noah Mitchell.
In the 1870 Michigan census, Charles and family were living in Ada, Kent Co., Michigan.
After Charles died, Sarah married Marshall Mitchell, son of Noah Mitchell.[125]
Charles was, according to family lore, cousin of Marshall son of Noah.[114]
Charles W. Mitchell is probably son of Darius Mitchell the brother of Noah Mitchell, based on the following reasoning.

Nancy Pringle, age 16, is found with Charles and Sarah (“Sally”) A. Mitchell in the 1861 North Gwillimbury census, living in a log house right in between two other log houses occupied by Sarah’s mother Elenor (“Ellen”) Barry (her second marriage) and family on one side, and Noah Mitchell and family on the other side.

Nancy was daughter of George and Sophia (Mitchell) Pringle. Sophia was daughter of Darius Mitchell the brother of Noah. If Charles was son of Darius, that would make Nancy Pringle his niece. Otherwise she would be more distantly related, being a first cousin once removed, which would seem less likely for Nancy to be staying with than a closer relative.

Darius is also found in the 1861 North Gwillimbury census with children aged 17 and younger at home, and wife age 44. Charles was 19 and apparently newly married. Age 19 would be an appropriate age for the next older child of Darius, and a wife age 44 could easily have had one or more children older than 17.

Finally, the other known brothers of Darius are much less fit to be Charles’s father.
Noah was, according to Jimmie Mitchell, Charles’s uncle not his father.
Elisha Jr.’s family moved to Wisconsin not Michigan.
Nelson wasn’t known to be married until 1839, whereas Charles was born 1832 when Nelson was only 18.
Nathaniel is another even younger brother listed by some.

It is also interesting (but possibly a mere coincidence) that Charles’ middle initial was “W.” (middle name unknown), and Darius’s wife’s maiden name was Willoughby. And Charles’s son was named Nathan Henry Mitchell. Darius also had a son named Nathan (which would be Charles’s brother, if I am correct). The name Henry would have come from the Sweet side though (Sarah’s brother David Henry Sweet, for one).
Children:
+37i.NATHAN HENRY4 MITCHELL, b. in Jan. 1863[24] in Ontario[24]; d. on 17 Aug. 1921 in Muskegon, Muskegon Co.; m. on 1 Jan. 1887 in Ravenna, Muskegon Co. (AIZ-29) MYRTA FRANCIS RICHNER, b. in Indiana, United States[18, 22, 26] in July 1865[24], d. in Ravenna, Muskegon Co.[3] on 14 March 1914[3], daughter of (AIZ-22) Daniel Charles and (GP-2) Alma Theresa (BOWDLE) RICHNER.
38ii.ELLA MATILDA JANE MITCHELL, b. on 30 Oct. 1868[114] in Michigan[20, 14, 12, 12, 13]; d. on 24 April 1902[126] in Casnovia Twp., Muskegon Co.[126].
15. JOSIAH3 MITCHELL (Darius2, Elisha1), son of (2) Darius2 and Mary Louise (WILLOUGHBY) MITCHELL, was born in Canada[113, 17, 105, 105], and died between June 1870 and 1950. He married ARVILLA _____, who was born in Ohio[17].

From the 12 Jan. 1852 census, in North Gwillimbury[113]:

NameOccupationBirthplaceAge at Next BirthdayGenderMarital Status
Darius MitchellyeomanCanada55M
Louisa MitchellCanada45FM
Alexander MitchellCanada18M
Laurilla MitchellCanada17F
Sarah MitchellCanada15F
Josiah MitchellCanada12MS
Philana MitchellCanada10FS
Nelson MitchellCanada3MS

From the 1 June 1870 census, in Ravenna, Muskegon, Michigan[17]:

Dwelling #Family #NameAgeGenderColorOccupationReal Estate ValuePersonal Estate ValueBirthplaceFather Foreign BornMother Foreign BornCannot ReadCannot Write
194183Mitchell Noah55MWFarmer4002550CanadaYYYY
Mitchell Betsey42FWKeeps HouseCanadaYYYY
Mitchell Mary14FWCanadaYYYY
Mitchell David G.H.1MWMichiganYY
195184Mitchell, Josiah30MWLabourCanadaYY
Mitchell, Arvilla26FWKeeps HouseOhio
Mitchell, James2MWMichiganY

[100, 105, 17, 113]
Child:
39i.JAMES4 MITCHELL, b. about 1867 in Michigan[17].
17. NELSON3 MITCHELL (Darius2, Elisha1), son of (2) Darius2 and Mary Louise (WILLOUGHBY) MITCHELL, was born in 1850[123] in North Gwillimbury[123], and died between June 1900 and 1960. He married (1st) in Orillia[123], on 13 Dec. 1872[123], AGNES WELWOOD, who was born in 1853[123] in Nasagarwga[123]. He married (2nd) in Georgina, York[124], on 17 Sept. 1878[124], ELIZA SHUTTLEWORTH, who was born in Aug. 1846[111] in Ontario[89].

From the 12 Jan. 1852 census, in North Gwillimbury[113]:

NameOccupationBirthplaceAge at Next BirthdayGenderMarital Status
Darius MitchellyeomanCanada55M
Louisa MitchellCanada45FM
Alexander MitchellCanada18M
Laurilla MitchellCanada17F
Sarah MitchellCanada15F
Josiah MitchellCanada12MS
Philana MitchellCanada10FS
Nelson MitchellCanada3MS

From the 2 April 1871 census, in Georgina, York North[112]:

Dwelling #Family #NameGenderAge at Next BirthdayBirthplaceReligionOriginOccupationMarital Status
140141Mitchell, DariusM80United StatesB. ChristianEnglishLabourerM
Mitchell, MaryF73OntarioB. ChristianEnglishM
Mitchell, NelsonM21OntarioB. ChristianEnglishLabourer
Anderson, WilliamM43OntarioB. ChristianScotchLabourerM
Anderson, SarahF38OntarioB. Christiannot knownM
Anderson, MatildaF7OntarioB. ChristianScotch

From the 4 April 1881 census, in North Gwillimbury[89]:

Dwelling #Family #NameGenderAgeBirthplaceReligionOriginOccupationMarital Status
184188Mitchell, NelsonM25OntarioMethodistEnglishLabourerM
Mitchell, ElizaF27OntarioMethodistEnglishM
Mitchell, EdwardM13OntarioMethodistEnglish
Mitchell, JamesM11OntarioMethodistEnglish
Mitchell, JohnM9OntarioMethodistEnglish
Mitchell, MaggieM6OntarioMethodistEnglish
Mitchell, CharlesM2OntarioMethodistEnglishFarm laborerS
Mitchell, DariusM65OntarioMethodistEnglishyeomanW

From the 1 June 1900 census, in Kimball, Saint Clair Co., Michigan[111]:

Dwelling #Family #NameRelationshipColorGenderBirth month and yearAgeMarital StatusYears of MarriageNumber of ChildrenChildren LivingBirthplaceFather's BirthplaceMother's BirthplaceImmigration YearYears in USNaturalizationOccupationMonths UnemployedAttended School Within the YearCan ReadCan WriteCan Speak EnglishHome Owned or RentedFarm or House# of Farm Schedule
218220Mitchell, NelsonHeadWhiteMJUN 185049M21CanadaCanadaCanada188911Al.Farmer0YesNoYesRentFarm174
Mitchell, ElizawifeWhiteFAUG 184653M2166CanadaEnglandEngland188911YesNoYes
Mitchell, CharlessonWhiteMFEB 188119SCanadaCanadaEngland188911Farm laborer3YesYesYes
Mitchell, WilliamsonWhiteMSEP 188514SCanadaCanadaEngland188911At schoolYesYesYesYes

[100, 105, 36, 123, 76, 111, 89, 112, 113]
The following other Mitchell children are found with Nelson and Darius Mitchell in the 1881 census, but more research is needed to determine their relationship:
Edward 13 (c.1868)
James 11 (c.1870)
John 9 (c.1872)
Maggie 6 (c.1875)

See https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/FM39-QLN for a birth 18 Aug 1870 in North Gwillimbury of a James Edward Mitchell, son of John Mitchell and Jane Atkinson and https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/FL5T-DFH for his death 6 June 1948 in Vancouver, BC.

See http://data2.collectionscanada.ca/1871/jpg/4396756_00269.jpg and http://data2.collectionscanada.ca/1871/jpg/4396756_00270.jpg for 1871 census in North Gwillinbury of
John Mitchell, 36, b. (c.1835) England,
Jane, 36, b. (c.1835) Ontario
Charles, 9
John G, 7
Mary E, 5
Franklin, 2
James E., 8/12 mo (b. August).
next door to Orin Sweet family.
Children of: Nelson3 MITCHELL and Eliza SHUTTLEWORTH:
40i.CHARLES4 MITCHELL, b. in Feb. 1881[111] in Ontario[89].
41ii.WILLIAM MITCHELL, b. in Sept. 1885[111] in Canada[111].
19. SOPHIA3 MITCHELL (Darius2, Elisha1), daughter of (2) Darius2 and Mary Louise (WILLOUGHBY) MITCHELL, was born on 27 Aug. 1826[142, 155] in Canada West[59], and died on 6 Nov. 1910[118] in North Gwillimbury[118]. She married (AHV-1) GEORGE PRINGLE, who was born in 1830[154] in Canada West[59], and died in 1894[154] in Georgina, York[154].

From the 12 Jan. 1852 census, in North Gwillimbury[106]:

NameOccupationBirthplaceReligionAge at Next BirthdayGenderMarital StatusAttending SchoolHouses|KindHouses|Stories
George PrindleyeomanCanadaMethodist36MMLog1
Sophia PrindleCanadaMethodist25FM
Darius PrindleCanadaMethodist9MSY
Nancy PrindleCanada WestMethodist7FSY
Simeon PringleCanada WestMethodist4MS
Nelson PringleCanada WestMethodist2MS

From the 14 Jan. 1861 census, in North Gwillimbury[59]:

NameOccupationBirthplaceReligionAge at Next BirthdayGenderMarital Status
George PringleFarmerCanada WestMethodist44MM
Sophia PringleCanada WestMethodist34FM
Nancy PringleCanada WestMethodist16FS
Simeon PringleCanada WestMethodist13MS
Nelson PringleCanada WestMethodist12MS
George PringleCanada WestMethodist5MS
John PringleCanada WestMethodist3MS
Charles PringleCanada WestMethodist1MS

From the 4 April 1881 census, in North Gwillimbury[91]:

Dwelling #Family #NameGenderAgeBirthplaceReligionOriginOccupationMarital Status
191195Pringle, SophiaF52EnglandMethodistScotchM
Pringle, CharlesM20OntarioMethodistScotchLabourer
Pringle, ElenF15OntarioMethodistScotch

[118, 142, 155, 101, 77, 91, 106, 59]
Children: See (AHV-1) George PRINGLE
20. NATHAN3 MITCHELL (Darius2, Elisha1), son of (2) Darius2 and Mary Louise (WILLOUGHBY) MITCHELL, was born on 30 June 1829[149] in Ontario[37, 79, 60], and died on 30 Oct. 1900[149, 115] in Scott[149, 115]. He married SARAH ANN TOMLINSON, who was born on 4 Oct. 1837[150] in Ontario[37, 79, 60], and died on 19 Feb. 1884[117] in Georgina, York[117].

From the 12 Jan. 1852 census, in North Gwillimbury[110]:

NameOccupationBirthplaceReligionAge at Next BirthdayGenderMarital StatusFamily MemberAttending SchoolHouses|KindHouses|Stories
Nelson MitchellyeomanCanadaUnitarian Christian Church38MMFrame2
Elizabeth MitchellCanadaUnitarian Christian Church26FM
Bartlett MitchellCanadaUnitarian Christian Church12MSY
Clarissa MitchellCanadaUnitarian Christian Church8FSY
Salla MitchellCanadaUnitarian Christian Church6FSY
Seth MitchellCanadaUnitarian Christian Church4MSY
Emily MitchellCanadaUnitarian Christian Church2FS
Sarah MitchellNew YorkUnitarian Christian Church78FW
Nathaniel MitchellLabourerCanadaChristian23MSN
Cloe MitchellCanada40FMN
Mary MitchellCanada2FSN

From the 14 Jan. 1861 census, in North Gwillimbury[60]:

NameOccupationBirthplaceReligionAge at Next BirthdayGenderMarital Status
Nathan MitchelFarmerONChristian32MM
Sarah A. MitchelONChristian25FM
Jane A. MitchelONChristian5FS
George HanesFarmerNY71MM
Diana HanesON53FM
Phebe MitchelON17FS
Marshall MitchelON12MS

From the 2 April 1871 census, in Canada[37]:

Dwelling #Family #NameGenderAge at Next BirthdayBirthplaceReligionOriginOccupationMarital Status
169170Mitchell, NathanM41ONChristianEnglishFarmerM
Mitchell, Sarah AnnF33ONChristianEnglishM
Mitchell, JaneF14OntarioChristianEnglishS
Mitchell, PhilottaF10OntarioChristianEnglishS
Mitchell, IdiaF6OntarioChristianEnglishS
Mitchell, RoseF1OntarioChristianEnglishS

From the 4 April 1881 census, in Georgina, York North[79]:

Dwelling #Family #NameGenderAgeBirthplaceReligionOriginOccupationMarital Status
8184Mitchell, NathanM52OntarioChristianEnglishFarmerM
Mitchell, SarahF44OntarioChristianEnglishM
Mitchell, IdaF16OntarioChristianEnglish
Mitchell, RosaF11OntarioChristianEnglishS
Mitchell, DavidM8OntarioChristianEnglishS
Mitchell, WilmottM5OntarioChristianEnglishS
Mitchell, JosephM1OntarioChristianEnglishS

[149, 115, 151, 75, 79, 37, 110, 60]
Children:
42i.IDA4 MITCHELL, b. about 3 April 1865 in Ontario[37, 79].
43ii.ROSE BELL MITCHELL, b. on 12 April 1870[83] in Georgina, York[83]; m. on 28 Sept. 1887[146] in Georgina, York[146] JAMES ALBERT YORK.
44iii.DAVID MITCHELL, b. on 26 March 1873[80] in Georgina, York[80].
45iv.WILMOT MITCHELL, b. on 4 Oct. 1875[84] in Georgina, York[84]; m. on 28 Sept. 1898[148] in North Gwillimbury[148] JENNIE BARKER, b. about 1852[148].
46v.JOSEPH MITCHELL, b. on 15 Sept. 1879[82] in Georgina, York[82]; m. on 29 June 1904[147] in Scott[147] M. V. FOOTE.
47vi.JANE ANN MITCHELL, b. about 14 Jan. 1857 in Ontario[37, 60]; m. on 26 Jan. 1875[143] in Georgina, York[143] CHARLES WINFIELD.
48vii.PHILOTTA G. MITCHELL, b. about 1861 in Ontario[37]; d. on 26 Oct. 1934[116] in Ontario[116]; m. on 15 Sept. 1880[145] in Georgina, York[145] JAMES ALBERT DAFOE.
49viii.GEORGE MITCHELL, b. on 8 June 1878[81] in Georgina, York[81].
21. SYLVANUS3 MITCHELL (Elisha2, Elisha1), son of (4) Elisha2 and (WA-60) Althea (HUNTLEY) MITCHELL, was born in June 1828[73] in Canada West[71, 70], and died between June 1900 and 1938. He married ANNA _____, who was born in July 1835[73] in New York[73].

From the 1 June 1850 census, in Racine, Racine, Wisconsin[85]:

Dwelling #Family #NameAgeGenderOccupationBirthplace
78Ira Dean40MMasonConnecticut
Polly Dean40FNew York
Louisa Dean7FWisconsin
Aseneth Dean5FWisconsin
Charles Dean1MWisconsin
John Lee20MMasonEngland
Joshua Lee19MMasonEngland
Sylvanus Mitchel21MMasonCanada

From the 1 June 1855 census, in Bovina Twp., Outagamie Co., Wisconsin[69]:

Name: Sylvanus Mitchell
1 White male 0+ (Sylvanus 26-28)
1 White female 0+ (Anna 19)

From the 1 June 1860 census, in Hortonia, Outagamie Co.[70]:

Dwelling #Family #NameAgeGenderOccupationReal Estate ValuePersonal Estate ValueBirthplace
14731439Sylvanus Mitchel30MFarmer400390Canada West
Anna Mitchel25FHousewifeNew York
George Mitchel5MWisconsin
Martha Mitchel4FWisconsin
Eugene Mitchel2M

From the 1 June 1870 census, in Hortonia[71]:

Dwelling #Family #NameAgeGenderColorOccupationReal Estate ValuePersonal Estate ValueBirthplace
5151Mitchel, Sylvanus42MWStone mason1000100Canada West
Mitchel, Anna34FWKeeping houseNY
Mitchel, George A.14MWAt homeWI
Mitchel, Martha A.14FWWI
Mitchel, Eugene12MWAt home
Mitchel, Marian9FW
Mitchel, Althea69FWAt home

From the 1 June 1875 census, in Dale, Outagamie Co.[72]:

Name: Sylvanus Mitchell
3 White males 0+ (Sylvanus 46-48, Anna 39, Eugene 17)
6 White females 0+ (Althea 74-77, Martha 19, Marian 14, ?, ?, ?)

From the 1 June 1900 census, in Buffalo, Newton Co., Missouri, United States[73]:

Dwelling #Family #NameRelationshipColorGenderBirth month and yearAgeMarital StatusYears of MarriageNumber of ChildrenChildren LivingBirthplaceFather's BirthplaceMother's BirthplaceOccupationMonths UnemployedAttended School Within the YearCan ReadCan WriteCan Speak EnglishHome Owned or RentedHome Owned Free or MortgagedFarm or House# of Farm Schedule
9292Mitchell, SylvanusHeadWhiteMJUN 182872M50CanadaVermontVermontFarmer0YesYesYesOwnFreeFarm91
Mitchell, AnnaWifeWhiteFJUL 183564M5077New YorkNew YorkNew YorkHousewifeYesYesYes
Mitchell, LuellaDaughterWhiteF187426SWisconsinCanadaNew YorkYesYesYes
Mitchell, Althagrand daughterWhiteFOCT 188910SMissouriWisconsinWisconsinYesYesYesYes

[46, 70, 71, 69, 135, 40, 73, 72, 42, 42, 85]
Children:
50i.GEORGE4 MITCHEL, b. about 1 June 1855 in Wisconsin[71, 70].
51ii.MARTHA MITCHEL, b. about 1855 in Wisconsin[71, 70].
52iii.EUGENE MITCHEL, b. about 1857.
53iv.MARIAN MITCHEL, b. about 1860.
54v.LUELLA MITCHELL, b. in 1874[73] in Wisconsin[73].
22. EZRA BARTLETT3 MITCHELL (Nelson2, Elisha1), son of (7) Nelson2 and Elizabeth (OGLEBY) MITCHELL, was born in Ontario[67, 58], and died between 2 April 1871 and 1951. He married SUSAN _____, who was born in Ireland[67].

From the 12 Jan. 1852 census, in North Gwillimbury[110]:

NameOccupationBirthplaceReligionAge at Next BirthdayGenderMarital StatusFamily MemberAttending SchoolHouses|KindHouses|Stories
Nelson MitchellyeomanCanadaUnitarian Christian Church38MMFrame2
Elizabeth MitchellCanadaUnitarian Christian Church26FM
Bartlett MitchellCanadaUnitarian Christian Church12MSY
Clarissa MitchellCanadaUnitarian Christian Church8FSY
Salla MitchellCanadaUnitarian Christian Church6FSY
Seth MitchellCanadaUnitarian Christian Church4MSY
Emily MitchellCanadaUnitarian Christian Church2FS
Sarah MitchellNew YorkUnitarian Christian Church78FW
Nathaniel MitchellLabourerCanadaChristian23MSN
Cloe MitchellCanada40FMN
Mary MitchellCanada2FSN

From the 14 Jan. 1861 census, in North Gwillimbury[58]:

NameOccupationBirthplaceReligionAge at Next BirthdayGenderMarital StatusAttending School Within the Year
Nelson MitchellyeomanOntarioChristian48MM
Elizabeth MitchellOntarioChristian38FM
Ezra Bartlett MitchellOntarioChristian21MS
Claracy MitchellOntarioChristian17FSY
Sarah MitchellOntarioChristian15FSY
Seth MitchellOntarioChristian13MSY
Nelson MitchellOntarioChristian9MSY
Elisha MitchellOntarioChristian8MSY
Frances MitchellOntarioChristian5MS
Hugh MitchellOntarioChristian3MS
Sarah MitchellUnited StatesChristian85FS

From the 2 April 1871 census, in North Gwillimbury[67]:

Dwelling #Family #NameGenderAge at Next BirthdayBirthplaceReligionOriginOccupationMarital Status
1414Mitchell, BartlettM30OntarioChristianEnglishLaborerM
Mitchell, SusanF30IrelandChurch of EnglandIrishM
Mitchell, James W.M4OntarioChurch of EnglandEnglishS
Mitchell, ElizabethF2OntarioChurch of EnglandEnglishS

[104, 110, 30, 58, 66, 67]
Children:
55i.JAMES W.4 MITCHELL, b. about 1867 in Ontario[67].
56ii.ELIZABETH MITCHELL, b. about 1869 in Ontario[67].
34. MARSHALL3 MITCHELL (Noah2, Elisha1), son of (8) Noah2 and (TU-2) Elizabeth (HAINES) MITCHELL, was born in Ontario[60], and died between June 1880 and 1958. He married (ANQ-2) SARA ANN SWEET, daughter of (ANQ-1) _____ and Elenor (_____) SWEET, who was born about 1842[44, 47] in Ontario[57], and died in 1894[114] in Ravenna, Muskegon Co.[114].

From the 1 June 1850 census, in Ellington[68]:

Dwelling #Family #NameAgeGenderOccupationReal Estate ValueBirthplace
117117Noah Mitchell33MFarmer300Canada
Elizabeth Mitchell22FKeeps HouseCanada
Elisha Benett10MCanada
David Perl32MCarpenterConnecticut
Marshall Mitchell2MFarmerCanada

From the 14 Jan. 1861 census, in North Gwillimbury[60]:

NameOccupationBirthplaceReligionAge at Next BirthdayGenderMarital Status
Nathan MitchelFarmerONChristian32MM
Sarah A. MitchelONChristian25FM
Jane A. MitchelONChristian5FS
George HanesFarmerNY71MM
Diana HanesON53FM
Phebe MitchelON17FS
Marshall MitchelON12MS

From the 1 June 1880 census, in Ravenna, Muskegon Co.[20]:

Dwelling #Family #NameColorGenderAgeBirth MonthDateRelationshipMarital StatusOccupationAttended School Within the YearBirthplaceFather's BirthplaceMother's Birthplace
5760Mitchel MarshalWhiteM32MFarmerCANCANCAN
Mitchel Sarah A.WhiteF37wifeMKeeping houseCANCANCAN
Mitchel EbenWhiteM3SonSMICANCAN
Mitchel LuWhiteM8/12SeptSEP 1879SonSMICANCAN
61Barry, HenryWhiteM28wife's brotherMFarm laborerCANIrelandCAN
Barry, AmeliaWhiteF23WifeMKeeping houseMINYNY
Mitchel, MatildaWhiteF12wife's daughterSAt schoolYesMICANCAN

[114, 10, 19, 68, 60, 20]
Children:
57i.EBEN4 MITCHEL, b. about 1876 in Michigan[20].
+58ii.LEWIS DAVID MITCHELL, b. in Sept. 1879[20] in Michigan[88, 87, 86]; d. on 26 Sept. 1930[132] in Phoenix, Maricopa Co., Arizona, United States[132]; m. MARGARET AGNES MCBETH, b. in Kansas, United States[88, 87, 86] on 22 April 1884[131], d. in Phoenix[131] on 5 Feb. 1933[131].

Generation Four

37. NATHAN HENRY4 MITCHELL (Charles W.3, Darius2, Elisha1), son of (11) Charles W.3 and (ANQ-2) Sara Ann (SWEET) MITCHELL, was born in Jan. 1863[24] in Ontario[24], died on 17 Aug. 1921 in Muskegon, Muskegon Co. and was buried in Ravenna, Muskegon Co. He married in Ravenna, Muskegon Co., on 1 Jan. 1887, (AIZ-29) MYRTA FRANCIS RICHNER, daughter of (AIZ-22) Daniel Charles and (GP-2) Alma Theresa (BOWDLE) RICHNER, who was born in July 1865[24] in Indiana[18, 22, 26], died on 14 March 1914[3] in Ravenna, Muskegon Co.[3], and was buried on 18 March 1914[3] in Ravenna, Muskegon Co.[3].

From the 1 June 1870 census, in Ada[14]:

Dwelling #Family #NameAgeGenderColorOccupationPersonal Estate ValueBirthplaceFather Foreign BornMother Foreign BornRight to Vote Denied
4647Mitchell Charles37MWFarmer600CANYYY
Mitchell Sarah27FWKeeping houseCANY
Mitchell Nathan9MWCANYY
Mitchell Matilda1FWMIYY

From the 1 June 1880 census, in Chester Twp., Ottawa Co., Michigan[55]:

Dwelling #Family #NameColorGenderAgeRelationshipMarital StatusOccupationBirthplaceFather's BirthplaceMother's Birthplace
307316Hamill, GurnseyWhiteM63MFarmerOhioNew JerseyNew York
Hamill, LucevaWhiteF54WifeMKeeping HouseOhioPennsylvaniaPennsylvania
Hamill, Joseph I.WhiteM19SonSat HomeMichiganOhioOhio
Mitchel, NathanWhiteM19BoarderSFarm LaborerMichiganCanadaCanada

From the 1 June 1900 census, in Ravenna Twp., Muskegon Co.[24]:

NameRelationshipGenderBirth month and yearAgeMarital StatusBirthplaceFather's BirthplaceMother's BirthplaceOccupation
Mitchel NathanHeadMJAN 186337MONONONFarmer
Mitchel MertiewifeFJUL 186535MINOHOH
Mitchel MyrtledaughterFJUL 188812SMICAN
Mitchel MaudedaughterFOCT 189010SMICANOH
Mitchel CharlessonMFEB 18919SMICANOH

From the 15 April 1910 census, in Ravenna, Muskegon Co.[26]:

NameRelationshipGenderAgeMarital StatusBirthplaceFather's BirthplaceMother's BirthplaceImmigration YearOccupation
Mitchel NathanHeadM45MONONON1887Farmer
Mitchel MyrtiewifeF45MINOHOHNone
Mitchel MyrtledaughterF22SMIONINNone
Mitchel MauddaughterF20MMIONINNone
Mitchel LynnsonM4SMIONINNone
Elener BarrettgrandmotherF89WONONMANone
Michel CliffordsonM2SMIONINNone

From the 1 Jan. 1920 census, in Ravenna, Muskegon Co.[28]:

Dwelling #Family #NameRelationshipHome Owned or RentedHome Owned Free or MortgagedGenderColorAgeMarital StatusImmigration YearNaturalizationAttended School Within the YearCan ReadCan WriteBirthplaceMother TongueFather's BirthplaceFather's Mother TongueMother's BirthplaceMother's Mother TongueCan Speak EnglishOccupation|OccupationOccupation|IndustryEmployer, Employee, or Own Account# of Farm Schedule
8282Laubach, Mary E.HeadOwnedMortgagedFWhite72WdYesYesOhioPennsylvaniaPennsylvaniaYesTakes boardersOwn homeOA (Self-employed)
Mitchel, NathanBoarderMWhite56Wd1868NaturalizedYesYesCanadaEnglishCanadaEnglishCanadaEnglishYesLaborerWorks outWages or salary79
Mitchel, CliffordBoarderMWhite12SYesYesYesMichiganCanadaEnglishIndianaYesnone

[26, 24, 21, 50, 48, 55, 28, 12, 13, 14]
Muskegon County Marriage records-Book 3, p. 11[114]
Children:
+59i.MYRTLE ALICE5 MITCHELL, b. on 8 July 1887[2, 121] in Ravenna, Muskegon Co.[2, 121]; d. on 30 Nov. 1965 in Muskegon, Muskegon Co.; m. on 12 Dec. 1912[1, 119] in Ravenna, Muskegon Co.[1, 119] (DB-35) CHARLES WILLARD BALCOM, b. in Casnovia, Muskegon Co.[2, 121] on 4 July 1881[2, 121], d. in Muskegon, Muskegon Co. on 27 Aug. 1953, son of (DB-24) Edward R. and (LY-14) Eunice A. (COTTON) BALCOM.
+60ii.MAUDE F. MITCHELL, b. in Oct. 1890[24] in Michigan[24]; d. in Sept. 1938; m. (FO-1) RALPH H. BLUE, b. in 1889, d. in Grand Rapids, Kent Co. in 1955.
+61iii.CHARLES N. MITCHELL, b. in Feb. 1891[24] in Michigan[24]; d. on 14 Nov. 1966 in Muskegon, Muskegon Co.; m. (1) LIVING; m. (2) LIVING.
62iv.MINNIE MAY MITCHELL, b. on 17 Feb. 1895 in Ravenna, Muskegon Co.; d. in Jan. 1900 in Ravenna, Muskegon Co.
My Family Tree, compiled by Ruth Swanson in 1956
Muskegon County Death record
63v.WYNN MITCHELL, b. on 20 July 1897; d. on 19 June 1898 in Ravenna, Muskegon Co.
Muskegon Co. Death Record-Book 2, p. 220
Carrey Mitchell-11 months male
Muskegon Co. Birth Records-Carrie M. Mitchell-female
My Family Tree-son Wynn
Notes of Myrtle Mitchell Balcom-Wynn
64vi.VERNON MITCHELL, b. on 15 Sept. 1900[5] in Michigan[5]; d. on 20 Aug. 1902[5] in Ravenna Twp.[5].
My Family Tree, compiled by Ruth Swanson in 1956 - Vernon died
age of 1 yr. and 11 months
Muskegon Co. Death Record-Book 2, p. 306
Age 1 yr. 11 mo. 5 d.
Calculated birth date
+65vii.ERNEST LYNN MITCHELL, b. on 10 Nov. 1905 in Michigan[26]; d. in 1955 in Muskegon, Muskegon Co.; m. LIVING.
+66viii.CLIFFORD L. MITCHELL, b. on 15 June 1907 in Michigan[28, 26]; d. on 6 Sept. 1961; m. LIVING.
58. LEWIS DAVID4 MITCHELL (Marshall3, Noah2, Elisha1), son of (34) Marshall3 and (ANQ-2) Sara Ann (SWEET) (MITCHELL) MITCHELL, was born in Sept. 1879[20] in Michigan[88, 87, 86], and died on 26 Sept. 1930[132] in Phoenix[132]. He married MARGARET AGNES MCBETH, who was born on 22 April 1884[131] in Kansas[88, 87, 86], and died on 5 Feb. 1933[131] in Phoenix[131].

From the 1 June 1880 census, in Ravenna, Muskegon Co.[20]:

Dwelling #Family #NameColorGenderAgeBirth MonthDateRelationshipMarital StatusOccupationAttended School Within the YearBirthplaceFather's BirthplaceMother's Birthplace
5760Mitchel MarshalWhiteM32MFarmerCANCANCAN
Mitchel Sarah A.WhiteF37wifeMKeeping houseCANCANCAN
Mitchel EbenWhiteM3SonSMICANCAN
Mitchel LuWhiteM8/12SeptSEP 1879SonSMICANCAN
61Barry, HenryWhiteM28wife's brotherMFarm laborerCANIrelandCAN
Barry, AmeliaWhiteF23WifeMKeeping houseMINYNY
Mitchel, MatildaWhiteF12wife's daughterSAt schoolYesMICANCAN

From the 15 April 1910 census, in Peoria, Ottawa Co., Oklahoma[86]:

Dwelling #Family #NameRelationshipGenderColorAgeMarital StatusYears of MarriageNumber of ChildrenChildren LivingBirthplaceFather's BirthplaceMother's BirthplaceLanguageOccupationPlace of WorkEmployer, Employee, or Own AccountUnemployedWeeks UnemployedCan ReadCan WriteAttended School Within the YearHome Owned or RentedFarm or House
9595Mitchell, Lewis D.HeadMWhite29M19MICanadaCanadaEnglishSuperintendentLead mineWagesno12YesYesRentedHouse
Mitchell, AgneswifeFWhite26M1943KansasScotlandIndianaEnglishnoneYesYes
Mitchell, Lewis M.sonMWhite8SMissouriMichiganKansasnoneYesYesYes
Mitchell, Walter E.sonMWhite5SMissouriMichiganKansasnone
Mitchell, LalesonMWhite1SMissouriMichiganKansasnone

From the 1 Jan. 1920 census, in Quapaw Twp., Ottawa Co., Oklahoma[87]:

Dwelling #Family #NameRelationshipHome Owned or RentedHome Owned Free or MortgagedGenderColorAgeMarital StatusAttended School Within the YearCan ReadCan WriteBirthplaceFather's BirthplaceFather's Mother TongueMother's BirthplaceMother's Mother TongueCan Speak EnglishOccupation|OccupationOccupation|IndustryEmployer, Employee, or Own Account
7474Mitchell, Lewis D.HeadOwnedFreeMWhite38MYesYesMICanadaEnglishCanadaEnglishYesMinerLead & zincWages or salary
Mitchell, AgneswifeFWhite35MYesYesKSScotlandEnglishIndianaYesnone
Mitchell, LewissonMWhite17SYesYesMOMIKSYesmachinistmachine shopWages or salary
Mitchell, ElwoodsonMWhite15SYesYesYesMOMIKSYesnone
Mitchell, LafesonMWhite12SYesYesYesMOMIKSYesnone
Mitchell, PaulsonMWhite7SYesOklahomaMIKSYes
Mitchell, LeonardsonMWhite5SOklahomaMIKSYes

From the 1 April 1930 census, in Sunnyside, Maricopa Co.[88]:

Dwelling #Family #NameRelationshipHome Data|Owned?Home Data|Value or Monthly RentalHome Data|On a FarmPersonal|SexPersonal|ColorPersonal|AgePersonal|Marital ConditionPersonal|Age at First MarriageEducation|Attended School Within the YearEducation|Can Read and WriteBirthplaceFather's BirthplaceMother's BirthplaceCitizenship|Can Speak EnglishIndustry|OccupationIndustry|Place of WorkIndustry|Class of WorkerEmployment|At work yesterday
4040Mitchell, Louis D.HeadRented25noMW48M20NYMICanada FrenchCanada FrenchYnone
Mitchell, AgneswifeFW45M17NYKSScotlandIndianaYnone
Mitchell, PaulsonMW18SNYOKMIKSYCitrus handCitrusWage or salary workerY
Mitchell, LenardsonMW15SYYOKMIKSYnone

[47, 25, 86, 38, 87, 39, 88, 132, 6, 20]
Children:
67i.LOUIS MARSHALL5 MITCHELL, b. on 6 Feb. 1902[7] in Joplin, Missouri[7]; d. on 24 April 1960[7] in Longview, Gregg Co., Texas[7].
68ii.ELWOOD WALTER MITCHELL, b. on 28 June 1904[9] in Joplin[9]; d. on 23 Nov. 1967[9] in Houston, Harris Co., Texas[9].
69iii.LAFE HERBERT MITCHELL, b. on 28 Aug. 1908[8] in Missouri[87, 86]; d. on 5 March 1982[8] in Mesquite, Dallas Co., Texas[8].
70iv.PAUL L. MITCHELL, b. on 8 March 1912[6] in Oklahoma[88, 87]; d. on 7 Jan. 1982[6] in Wichita Falls, Wichita Co., Texas[6].
71v.LIVING.

Generation Five

59. MYRTLE ALICE5 MITCHELL (Nathan Henry4, Charles W.3, Darius2, Elisha1), daughter of (37) Nathan Henry4 and (AIZ-29) Myrta Francis (RICHNER) MITCHELL, was born on 8 July 1887[2, 121] in Ravenna, Muskegon Co.[2, 121], died on 30 Nov. 1965 in Muskegon, Muskegon Co. and was buried on 2 Dec. 1965 in Ravenna, Muskegon Co. She married in Ravenna, Muskegon Co.[1, 119], on 12 Dec. 1912[1, 119], (DB-35) CHARLES WILLARD BALCOM, son of (DB-24) Edward R. and (LY-14) Eunice A. (COTTON) BALCOM, who was born on 4 July 1881[2, 121] in Casnovia[2, 121], died on 27 Aug. 1953 in Muskegon, Muskegon Co., and was buried on 30 Aug. 1953 in Ravenna, Muskegon Co.

From the 1 June 1900 census, in Ravenna Twp.[24]:

NameRelationshipGenderBirth month and yearAgeMarital StatusBirthplaceFather's BirthplaceMother's BirthplaceOccupation
Mitchel NathanHeadMJAN 186337MONONONFarmer
Mitchel MertiewifeFJUL 186535MINOHOH
Mitchel MyrtledaughterFJUL 188812SMICAN
Mitchel MaudedaughterFOCT 189010SMICANOH
Mitchel CharlessonMFEB 18919SMICANOH

From the 15 April 1910 census, in Ravenna, Muskegon Co.[26]:

NameRelationshipGenderAgeMarital StatusBirthplaceFather's BirthplaceMother's BirthplaceImmigration YearOccupation
Mitchel NathanHeadM45MONONON1887Farmer
Mitchel MyrtiewifeF45MINOHOHNone
Mitchel MyrtledaughterF22SMIONINNone
Mitchel MauddaughterF20MMIONINNone
Mitchel LynnsonM4SMIONINNone
Elener BarrettgrandmotherF89WONONMANone
Michel CliffordsonM2SMIONINNone

From the 1 Jan. 1920 census, in Ravenna Twp.[52]:

Dwelling #Family #NameRelationshipHome Owned or RentedGenderColorAgeMarital StatusCan ReadCan WriteBirthplaceFather's BirthplaceFather's Mother TongueMother's BirthplaceCan Speak EnglishOccupation|OccupationOccupation|IndustryEmployer, Employee, or Own Account# of Farm Schedule
233233Balcom, CharlesHeadRMW37MYesYesMICanadaL.C.INYesFarmerGen. FarmingE151
Balcom, MyrtleWifeFW32MYesYesMICanadaL.CINYesNone
Balcom, EllisSonMW2 11/12SMIMIMINone
Richner, Daniel C.Grandfather-in-lawMW78WYesYesOHPAPAYesNone

From the 1 April 1930 census, in Ravenna Twp.[29]:

Dwelling #Family #NameRelationshipHome Data|Owned?Home Data|On a FarmPersonal|SexPersonal|ColorPersonal|AgePersonal|Marital ConditionPersonal|Age at First MarriageEducation|Attended School Within the YearEducation|Can Read and WriteBirthplaceFather's BirthplaceMother's BirthplaceCitizenship|Can Speak EnglishIndustry|OccupationIndustry|Place of WorkIndustry|Class of Worker
121132Charles Willard BalcomHeadOYesMW48M31noyesMICanada EnglishINyesFarmerGeneral FarmO
Myrtle Alice BalcomwifeFW42M25noyesMICanada EnglishINyesNone
Ellis Charles BalcomsonMW13SyesyesMIMIMIyesNone
Dorothy Alma BalcomdaughterFW8 5/12SyesMIMIMINone

[2, 27, 121, 24, 29, 26, 50, 51, 52, 54, 53]
Children: See (DB-35) Charles Willard BALCOM
60. MAUDE F.5 MITCHELL (Nathan Henry4, Charles W.3, Darius2, Elisha1), daughter of (37) Nathan Henry4 and (AIZ-29) Myrta Francis (RICHNER) MITCHELL, was born in Oct. 1890[24] in Michigan[24], died in Sept. 1938 and was buried in Ravenna, Muskegon Co. She married (FO-1) RALPH H. BLUE, who was born in 1889, died in 1955 in Grand Rapids, and was buried on 7 Feb. 1955 in Ravenna Cemetery, Ravenna, Muskegon Co.

From the 1 June 1900 census, in Ravenna Twp.[24]:

NameRelationshipGenderBirth month and yearAgeMarital StatusBirthplaceFather's BirthplaceMother's BirthplaceOccupation
Mitchel NathanHeadMJAN 186337MONONONFarmer
Mitchel MertiewifeFJUL 186535MINOHOH
Mitchel MyrtledaughterFJUL 188812SMICAN
Mitchel MaudedaughterFOCT 189010SMICANOH
Mitchel CharlessonMFEB 18919SMICANOH

From the 15 April 1910 census, in Ravenna, Muskegon Co.[26]:

NameRelationshipGenderAgeMarital StatusBirthplaceFather's BirthplaceMother's BirthplaceImmigration YearOccupation
Mitchel NathanHeadM45MONONON1887Farmer
Mitchel MyrtiewifeF45MINOHOHNone
Mitchel MyrtledaughterF22SMIONINNone
Mitchel MauddaughterF20MMIONINNone
Mitchel LynnsonM4SMIONINNone
Elener BarrettgrandmotherF89WONONMANone
Michel CliffordsonM2SMIONINNone

[26, 24, 50]
My Family Tree, compiled by Ruth Swanson in 1956
Muskegon Co. Birth records-Microfilm at LDS library
Tombsone-Ravenna Cemetery, Ravenna, Muskegon, Mich.
Children: See (FO-1) Ralph H. BLUE
61. CHARLES N.5 MITCHELL (Nathan Henry4, Charles W.3, Darius2, Elisha1), son of (37) Nathan Henry4 and (AIZ-29) Myrta Francis (RICHNER) MITCHELL, was born in Feb. 1891[24] in Michigan[24], died on 14 Nov. 1966 in Muskegon, Muskegon Co. and was buried on 17 Nov. 1966 in Ravenna, Muskegon Co. He married (1st) LIVING. He married (2nd) LIVING.

From the 1 June 1900 census, in Ravenna Twp.[24]:

NameRelationshipGenderBirth month and yearAgeMarital StatusBirthplaceFather's BirthplaceMother's BirthplaceOccupation
Mitchel NathanHeadMJAN 186337MONONONFarmer
Mitchel MertiewifeFJUL 186535MINOHOH
Mitchel MyrtledaughterFJUL 188812SMICAN
Mitchel MaudedaughterFOCT 189010SMICANOH
Mitchel CharlessonMFEB 18919SMICANOH

[24, 50]
Children of: Charles N.5 MITCHELL and LIVING:
72i.LIVING.
73ii.LIVING.
74iii.LIVING.
75iv.LIVING.
76v.LIVING.
65. ERNEST LYNN5 MITCHELL (Nathan Henry4, Charles W.3, Darius2, Elisha1), son of (37) Nathan Henry4 and (AIZ-29) Myrta Francis (RICHNER) MITCHELL, was born on 10 Nov. 1905 in Michigan[26], died in 1955 in Muskegon, Muskegon Co. and was buried in Grant, Newaygo Co., Michigan. He married LIVING.

From the 15 April 1910 census, in Ravenna, Muskegon Co.[26]:

NameRelationshipGenderAgeMarital StatusBirthplaceFather's BirthplaceMother's BirthplaceImmigration YearOccupation
Mitchel NathanHeadM45MONONON1887Farmer
Mitchel MyrtiewifeF45MINOHOHNone
Mitchel MyrtledaughterF22SMIONINNone
Mitchel MauddaughterF20MMIONINNone
Mitchel LynnsonM4SMIONINNone
Elener BarrettgrandmotherF89WONONMANone
Michel CliffordsonM2SMIONINNone

[26]
Children:
77i.LIVING.
78ii.LIVING.
79iii.LIVING.
80iv.LIVING.
66. CLIFFORD L.5 MITCHELL (Nathan Henry4, Charles W.3, Darius2, Elisha1), son of (37) Nathan Henry4 and (AIZ-29) Myrta Francis (RICHNER) MITCHELL, was born on 15 June 1907 in Michigan[28, 26], died on 6 Sept. 1961 and was buried on 9 Sept. 1961 in Grant. He married LIVING.

From the 15 April 1910 census, in Ravenna, Muskegon Co.[26]:

NameRelationshipGenderAgeMarital StatusBirthplaceFather's BirthplaceMother's BirthplaceImmigration YearOccupation
Mitchel NathanHeadM45MONONON1887Farmer
Mitchel MyrtiewifeF45MINOHOHNone
Mitchel MyrtledaughterF22SMIONINNone
Mitchel MauddaughterF20MMIONINNone
Mitchel LynnsonM4SMIONINNone
Elener BarrettgrandmotherF89WONONMANone
Michel CliffordsonM2SMIONINNone

From the 1 Jan. 1920 census, in Ravenna, Muskegon Co.[28]:

Dwelling #Family #NameRelationshipHome Owned or RentedHome Owned Free or MortgagedGenderColorAgeMarital StatusImmigration YearNaturalizationAttended School Within the YearCan ReadCan WriteBirthplaceMother TongueFather's BirthplaceFather's Mother TongueMother's BirthplaceMother's Mother TongueCan Speak EnglishOccupation|OccupationOccupation|IndustryEmployer, Employee, or Own Account# of Farm Schedule
8282Laubach, Mary E.HeadOwnedMortgagedFWhite72WdYesYesOhioPennsylvaniaPennsylvaniaYesTakes boardersOwn homeOA (Self-employed)
Mitchel, NathanBoarderMWhite56Wd1868NaturalizedYesYesCanadaEnglishCanadaEnglishCanadaEnglishYesLaborerWorks outWages or salary79
Mitchel, CliffordBoarderMWhite12SYesYesYesMichiganCanadaEnglishIndianaYesnone

[26, 28]
My Family Tree compiled by Ruth Swanson in 1956
Children:
81i.LIVING.
82ii.LIVING.
83iii.LIVING.
84iv.LIVING.
85v.LIVING.



1. "Marriage Certificate".
2. "Birth Certificate".
3. State of Michigan, Certificate of Death, no. 5 (14 March 1914), Myrta Mitchell; digital image, Online Computer Library Center, Inc. (http://oclc.org : accessed 31 March 2013).
4. Ibid., no. 5 (9 May 1914), Sarah Anderson.
5. Ibid., no. 584 (20 August 1902), Vernon Mitchell.
6. State of Texas, death certificate, no. 04480 (January 7, 1982), Paul L. Mitchell; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
7. Ibid., no. 23471 (April 24, 1960), Lewis Marshall Mitchell.
8. Ibid., no. 25866 (March 5, 1982), Lafe Herbert Mitchell.
9. Ibid., no. 72808 (November 23, 1967), Elwood Walter Mitchell.
10. 1861 Canada Census, North Gwillimbury, York, Ontario; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
11. 1870 United States Federal Census, Ada, Kent Co., Michigan; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
12. Ibid., 7.
13. Ibid., 7, dwelling 46.
14. Ibid., 7, dwelling 46, family 47.
15. 1870 United States Federal Census, Ravenna, Muskegon, Michigan, 24; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
16. Ibid., 24, dwelling 194.
17. Ibid., 24, dwelling 194, family 183.
18. 1870 United States Federal Census, Ozark Twp., Anderson Co., Kansas, 1, dwelling 5, family 5; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
19. 1880 United States Federal Census, Ravenna, Muskegon Co., Michigan; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
20. Ibid., dwelling 57, family 60.
21. 1880 United States Federal Census, Chester, Ottawa Co., Michigan; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
22. 1880 United States Federal Census, Haring, Wexford Co., Michigan, 19D, dwelling 141, family 144; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
23. 1880 United States Federal Census, Kauffman Co., Texas; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
24. 1900 United States Federal Census, Ravenna Twp, Muskegon Co., Michigan; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
25. 1910 United States Federal Census, 5B, dwelling 95, family 95; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
26. 1910 United States Federal Census, Ravenna, Muskegon Co., Michigan; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
27. 1920 United States Federal Census, Ravenna Twp, Muskegon Co., Michigan, 9064, dwelling 233, family 233; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
28. 1920 United States Federal Census, Ravenna, Muskegon Co., Michigan, 4A, dwelling 82, family 82; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
29. 1930 United States Federal Census, Ravenna Twp, Muskegon Co., Michigan, 5B, dwelling 121, family 132; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
30. 1861 Canada Census, 16; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
31. Ibid., 36.
32. 1871 Canada Census, 13.
33. Ibid., 13, dwelling 48.
34. Ibid., 13, dwelling 48, family 48.
35. Ibid., 18, dwelling 52, family 52.
36. Ibid., 43, dwelling 140, family 141.
37. Ibid., 52, dwelling 169, family 170.
38. 1920 United States Federal Census, 4A, dwelling 74, family 74; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
39. 1930 United States Federal Census, 2A, dwelling 40, family 40; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
40. 1900 United States Federal Census, 5A, dwelling 92, family 92; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
41. 1850 United States Federal Census, 142, dwelling 866, family 870; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
42. Ibid., 35, dwelling 7, family 8.
43. 1790 United States Federal Census; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
44. 1870 United States Federal Census; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
45. Ibid., 3, dwelling 25, family 26.
46. Ibid., 7, dwelling 51, family 51.
47. 1880 United States Federal Census; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
48. Ibid., 34B, dwelling 307, family 316.
49. Ibid., 4D, dwelling 31, family 32.
50. 1900 United States Federal Census, Ravenna Twp., Muskegon Co., Michigan; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
51. 1920 United States Federal Census, Ravenna Twp., Muskegon Co., Michigan; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
52. Ibid., 9064, dwelling 233, family 233.
53. 1930 United States Federal Census, Ravenna Twp., Muskegon Co., Michigan; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
54. Ibid., 5B, dwelling 121, family 132.
55. 1880 United States Federal Census, Chester Twp., Ottawa Co., Michigan, 34B, dwelling 307, family 316; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
56. 1861 Canada Census, North Gwillimbury, York Co., Ontario; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
57. Ibid., 13.
58. Ibid., 16.
59. Ibid., 17.
60. Ibid., 19.
61. Ibid., 36.
62. 1900 United States Federal Census, Carlile, Malheur Co., Oregon, 4B, dwelling 109, family 109; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
63. 1881 Canada Census, Holland, Grey North Co., Ontario, 13, dwelling 55, family 58; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
64. 1871 Canada Census, North Gwillimbury, York Co., Ontario, 18, dwelling 52, family 52.
65. Ibid., 19, dwelling 55, family 55.
66. Ibid., 4.
67. Ibid., 4, dwelling 14, family 14.
68. 1850 United States Federal Census, Ellington, Brown Co., Wisconsin, 34, dwelling 117, family 117; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
69. 1855 Wisconsin State Census, Bovina Twp., Outagamie Co., Image 413.
70. 1860 United States Federal Census, Hortonia, Outagamie Co., Wisconsin, 197; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
71. 1870 United States Federal Census, Hortonia, Outagamie Co., Wisconsin, 7, dwelling 51, family 51; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
72. 1875 Wisconsin State Census, Dale, Outagamie Co., Image 215.
73. 1900 United States Federal Census, Buffalo, Newton Co., Missouri, 5A, dwelling 92, family 92; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
74. 1875 Minnesota State Census, 929, family 20.
75. 1881 Canada Census, 20, dwelling 81, family 84; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
76. Ibid., 38, dwelling 184, family 188.
77. Ibid., 39, dwelling 191, family 195.
78. Ibid., dwelling 210, family 214.
79. 1881 Canada Census, Georgina, York North, Ontario, 20, dwelling 81, family 84; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
80. "Ontario Births, 1869-1912," FamilySearch.org (https://familysearch.org/search/collection/1784212 : accessed 5 December 2013), David Mitchell.
81. Ibid., George Mitchell.
82. Ibid., Joseph Mitchell.
83. Ibid., Rose Bell Mitchell.
84. Ibid., Wilmont Mitchell.
85. 1850 United States Federal Census, Racine, Racine, Wisconsin, 35, dwelling 7, family 8; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
86. 1910 United States Federal Census, Peoria, Ottawa Co., Oklahoma, 5B, dwelling 95, family 95; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
87. 1920 United States Federal Census, Quapaw Twp., Ottawa Co., Oklahoma, 4A, dwelling 74, family 74; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
88. 1930 United States Federal Census, Sunnyside, Maricopa Co., Arizona, 2A, dwelling 40, family 40; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
89. 1881 Canada Census, North Gwillimbury, York Co., Ontario, 38, dwelling 184, family 188; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
90. Ibid., 38, dwelling 184, family 188, Darius Nelson, widower.
91. Ibid., 39, dwelling 191, family 195.
92. Ibid., dwelling 210, family 214.
93. 1850 United States Federal Census, Aurelius, Ingham Co., Michigan, 142, dwelling 866, family 870; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
94. 1870 United States Federal Census, Aurelius, Ingham Co., Michigan, 3, dwelling 25, family 26; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
95. 1880 United States Federal Census, Aurelius, Ingham Co., Michigan, 4D, dwelling 31, family 32; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
96. 1840 United States Federal Census, Putnam, Livingston Co., Michigan; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
97. 1894 Michigan State Census, population schedule, 88.
98. 1894 Michigan State Census, Aurelius, Ingham Co., population schedule, 88.
99. 1851 Canada Census, personal schedule.
100. Ibid., 23.
101. Ibid., 27.
102. Ibid., 41.
103. Ibid., 5.
104. Ibid., 9F.
105. 1851 Canada Census, North Gwillimbury, York Co., Ontario, personal schedule, 23.
106. Ibid., 27.
107. Ibid., 3.
108. Ibid., 41.
109. Ibid., 5.
110. Ibid., 9F.
111. 1900 United States Federal Census, Kimball, Saint Clair Co., Michigan, dwelling 218, family 220; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com).
112. 1871 Canada Census, Georgina, York North, Ontario, 43, dwelling 140, family 141.
113. 1851 Canada Census, North Gwillimbury, York Co., personal schedule, 23.
114. Jimmie Mitchell, Perryton, Texas, to Dave Thaler, e-mail. Jimmie D. & Carolyn H. Mitchell 2302 S. Elm Perryton TX 79070 Email received 5/13/2002
115. "Ontario Deaths,1869-1937 and Overseas Deaths, 1939-1947," database, FamilySearch.org (https://www.familysearch.org/s/collection/show#uri=http://search-api:8080/searchapi/search/collection/1307826), Nathan Mitchell. Also at Ancestry.com
116. Ibid., Philotta Defoe.
117. Ibid., Sarah Ann Mitchell.
118. Ibid., Sophia Pringle.
119. "Michigan Marriages 1868-1925," database, FamilySearch.org (https://www.familysearch.org/s/collection/show#uri=http://search-api:8080/searchapi/search/collection/1452395).
120. Ibid., Alexander Mitchell and Eliza Jane Griffin.
121. "Michigan Births 1867-1902," database, FamilySearch.org (https://www.familysearch.org/s/collection/show#uri=http://search-api:8080/searchapi/search/collection/1459684).
122. "Ontario, Canada, Marriages, 1801-1928," database, Ancestry.com (http://search.ancestry.com/search/db.aspx?dbid=7921), Nelson Michel.
123. Ibid., Nelson Mitchell and Agnes Welwood.
124. Ibid., Nelson Mitchell and Eliza Seecore.
125. Jimmie Mitchell, Descendants of Noah Mitchell of Canada (http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.ancestry.com/~mitchell001/noah_mitchell.html).
126. "Michigan, Deaths and Burials Index, 1867-1995," database, Ancestry.com (http://search.ancestry.com/search/db.aspx?dbid=2549 : accessed 27 November 2011), Matilda Street.
127. Ibid., Sarah Anderson.
128. FindAGrave (http://www.findagrave.com), memorial #103010297.
129. Ibid., memorial #103011021.
130. Ibid., memorial #30091641.
131. Ibid., memorial #61743328.
132. Ibid., memorial #62139926.
133. Ibid., memorial #89185580.
134. Ibid., memorial #89186328.
135. Thomas H. Ryan, History of Outagamie County, Wisconsin (Chicago: Goodspeed Historical Associates, 1911); transcription, Rays Place (http://www.rays-place.com/).
136. Lisa Hoffius, Bennett Family of Bedford & Somerset Counties, Pennsylvania (http://freepages.genealogy.rootsweb.ancestry.com/~bennett1/Aquilla.htm : accessed 24 November 2013).
137. Lisa Hoffius, "Re: Eunice Church & Bethuel Huntley," Church Family Genealogy Forum, 22 May 2002 (http://genforum.genealogy.com/church/messages/2326.html : accessed 24 November 2013).
138. Charles Pelham Mulvany and Graeme Mercer Adam, History of Toronto and County of York, Ontario (Toronto: C. B. Robinson, 1885), 165; digital images, Archive.org (http://www.archive.org : accessed 5 December 2013).
139. Ibid., 171.
140. Kevin Hackett, Our Family Genealogies (http://www.ourfamilygenealogies.com/familytree/ : accessed 1 December 2013), Nelson Mitchell.
141. Billie Wilde, "Diadema "Demmie" Mitchell - Ontario," Mitchell Family Genealogy Forum, 16 June 2009 (http://www.genforum.familytreemaker.com/mitchell/messages/15218.html : accessed 4 December 2013).
142. marylync1, Poulter/Smith/Connor Family Tree (http://trees.ancestry.com/tree/4485537/person/397407943/facts : accessed 5 December 2013).
143. "Ontario Marriages, 1869-1927," database, FamilySearch.org (https://familysearch.org/search/collection/1784216 : accessed 5 December 2013), Charles Winfield and Jane Ann Mitchell.
144. Ibid., David Titus Willson and Susanna Rose Mitchell.
145. Ibid., James Albert Dafoe and Philotta G. Mitchell.
146. Ibid., James Albert York and Rose Mitchell.
147. Ibid., Joseph Mitchell and M. V. Foote.
148. Ibid., Wilmot Mitchell and Jennie Barker.
149. R. Greer, Fountain Family Tree (http://wc.rootsweb.ancestry.com/cgi-bin/igm.cgi?op=GET&db=fountainfamily&id=P9633 : accessed 5 December 2013).
150. Ibid., Nathan Mitchell.
151. janispjones16, Pringle/Merchant Family Tree (http://trees.ancestry.com/tree/577968/person/243295047/facts : accessed 5 December 2013), Nathan Mitchell.
152. "Canadian Immigrant Records," Ancestry.com (http://search.ancestry.com/search/db.aspx?dbid=3795&enc=1 : accessed 5 December 2013), Darius Mitchell.
153. Raymond Kinney, A Grove of Family Trees (http://wc.rootsweb.ancestry.com/cgi-bin/igm.cgi?op=GET&db=rkinney14&id=I34208 : accessed 8 December 2013).
154. wendyawhitten, Norton (http://trees.ancestry.com/tree/29956603/family?fpid=12228135790 : accessed 8 December 2013), George Pringle.
155. Ibid., Sophia Mitchell.
156. "Upper Canada Land Petitions (1763-1865)," database, Library and Archives Canada (http://www.bac-lac.gc.ca/eng/discover/land/land-petitions-upper-canada-1763-1865/Pages/land-petitions-upper-canada.aspx : accessed 9 December 2013), Elisha Mitchell.
157. "Mann Cemetery Records," abstracts, Geocities (http://www.oocities.org/soho/museum/3731/cem.html : accessed 27 September 2014), Elisha Michel.
158. Howard W. Chapin, Rhode Island in the Colonial Wars (Providence, R.I.: Rhode Island Historical Society, 1918), 101; digital images, Archive.org (http://www.archive.org : accessed 27 September 2014).
159. David Steffens, Farmington, CT, to Dave Thaler, e-mail, 1 November 2014, "Elisha Mitchell."
160. Elaine Pavone, "Genealogists are Forebearing," database, Rootsweb (http://wc.rootsweb.ancestry.com/cgi-bin/igm.cgi?op=GET&db=pavone&id=I21943 : accessed 27 September 2014), Zebediah Mitchell.